top of page

When One Spouse Won't Downsize: A Solano Guide

Oct 19
5 min read

Updated: Oct 29

When one spouse wants to downsize and the other doesn’t, the standoff is almost never really about the house. One partner is thinking about the stairs, the yard, and the monthly upkeep. The other is thinking about the lemon tree planted in 1994 and the neighbors who show up with dinner. Both are right — and the way through is slower and kinder than most couples expect. Three things move a stuck conversation without forcing a decision: touring a few single-story homes with no obligation, pricing out one full year of staying put, and agreeing on a loose timeline with a real date on the calendar instead of “someday.”


When One Spouse Won't Downsize: A Solano Guide

One spouse has the boxes labeled and a Realtor's number saved in their phone. The other walks past the staircase every morning and says the house is fine. When one spouse won't downsize, the standoff can sit at the kitchen table for two years, and I have watched it happen with couples in Benicia, Vallejo, and Fairfield.


If that is your house right now, nothing is broken. Two people who love each other are looking at the same home and seeing different things, and the way through is slower and kinder than most couples expect.


Why you are rarely ready to downsize at the same time

The spouse who wants to move is usually thinking about the stairs, the yard, and the monthly upkeep. The spouse who wants to stay is thinking about the lemon tree planted in 1994, the pencil marks on the pantry door that track the kids growing up, and the neighbors who show up with dinner when someone is sick. Both pictures are true, and both deserve a seat at the table.


What helps is reframing the conversation away from “do we move or do we stay” and toward “what does the next chapter actually need to look like for both of us?” That is the difference between downsizing and right-sizing — and it is a distinction that tends to land differently with the spouse who is resistant. I wrote about it in the right-sizing vs. downsizing after 70 guide, and it is worth reading together before the conversation goes further.


Start with what each of you is afraid of

Give each person a sheet of paper and ask them to finish two sentences on their own: the thing I would hate to lose is, and the thing that worries me about staying is. Then compare the sheets over coffee, with no fixing and no rebuttals for the first ten minutes.


The fears usually turn out smaller and more specific than the argument you have been having. Someone dreads losing the workshop in the garage, and a workshop can become a line on a home search. Someone dreads a fall on the stairs, and that worry has answers that do not always involve a moving truck.


Run a low-pressure test before anyone signs anything

Opinions soften when they meet real information. Three small experiments tend to move a stuck conversation without forcing a decision.

  • Tour two or three single-story homes with no obligation, so the idea of a smaller place has a floor plan and a front door instead of staying a feeling. Before you go, it helps to know what to actually look for — not just square footage and countertops, but the details that decide whether a home works for the next ten or twenty years. I put together a guide on senior-friendly home features that actually matter that is worth skimming before the first walkthrough.

  • Price out one full year of staying put, including property tax, insurance, utilities, yard help, and the repairs you already know are coming, and write the total on the fridge.

  • Call a free local resource for a second set of eyes. Solano County Older and Disabled Adult Services works with residents age 60 and older, and Helping Hands Senior Resources offers free navigation for families in Solano, Yolo, and Napa Counties.


Bring in one neutral voice

Allison Costelow, RE/MAX Gold
DRE# 02134647 | Seniors Real Estate Specialists

A third person lowers the temperature in the room. That might be an adult daughter, a trusted friend, or a financial planner who can run the numbers without taking a side. I am happy to sit down with both of you, and because I started my career as a Certified Nursing Assistant, I tend to ask about the daily stuff first, like how the bathroom works at 2 a.m. and who mows the lawn in August.


Money questions deserve a professional too. Before you list, a tax professional can walk you through how a sale might affect your capital gains and your property tax situation, and an estate attorney can tell you how your home is titled and what that means for each of you.


Agree on a loose timeline

Someday is the enemy of every couple in this spot, and a date on the calendar works better. Try something like, we will sit down again the first Sunday in March, and until then each of us takes one small task. One of you measures the furniture that would fit in a smaller space. The other collects three quotes for the repairs the house needs if you stay.


If a health event or a change in mobility speeds things up, you will already have done half the thinking, and the decision will feel like yours instead of something that happened to you. You can find the full overview on my pillar page, Senior Downsizing and Right-Sizing in Solano County.


When you are both ready to talk through the house itself — what it is worth, what the timing looks like, and how a move fits into everything else you are managing — that conversation starts here.

At Legacy and Lifestyle Homes, I work with couples and families throughout Solano County at exactly this stage — helping both people feel heard, running the real numbers, and finding a path that works for the whole household, not just one side of the kitchen table.


📞 (707) 813-1643 — call or text anytime


And if you want practical guidance for wherever you are in this journey — follow along on Facebook and Instagram for weekly tips, local resources, and real talk about senior real estate in Solano County.


❓Questions couples ask me

What if my spouse refuses to talk about moving at all?

Start smaller than the move itself. Ask for twenty minutes touring one home, or a quote for a walk-in shower, so both options sit on the table with real numbers beside them.


Does downsizing mean leaving Solano County?

Not at all. Many couples stay in the same city and move to a single-story home a few miles away, which keeps their doctors, their friends, and the grocery store they already know within reach.


Who decides if we still disagree?

In general, the owners of record decide together, and how the home is titled can matter, so it is worth talking with an estate attorney or tax professional about your specific situation before any listing conversation.



About the Author:

Allison Costelow is a Seniors Real Estate Specialist® (SRES®), Certified Probate Expert, and Certified Senior Housing Professional serving Benicia and the greater San Francisco Bay Area. With $20M+ in local sales and a background in healthcare, Allison helps seniors and families navigate downsizing, estate transitions, and new beginnings with clarity and care. Learn more about Allison →


​​- Allison Costelow, RE/MAX Gold
DRE# 02134647 | Seniors Real Estate Specialists

Comments


Re/Max Gold logo
Allison Costelow, Realtor

TO CONTACT OUR TEAM 

PLEASE CALL OR EMAIL US:

426 First Street
Benicia, CA 94510

Allison Costelow
Realtor®  DRE#02134647

Legacy and Lifestyle Homes
  • Facebook
  • Instagram
  • LinkedIn
  • YouTube
  • TikTok
  • Screenshot 2026-09-20 152211

👉 Find me on Zillow and Yelp

ALTERNATIVELY YOU CAN FILL

IN THE FOLLOWING CONTACT FORM:

Thanks for submitting!

CSHP Logo
SRES Logo
NAR Logo

​

Allison Costelow, Realtor® serving Benicia, Solano & Contra Costa Counties

bottom of page